Premium Content:

Press Council finds against News Corp titles over trans coverage

The Australian Press Council has found a swag of News Corp papers broke Australia’s standards for journalism over their reporting of a school shooting in Canada where the offender was a young transgender woman.

The Press Council considered whether its Standards of Practice were breached by a print article published on 13 February 2026 in the Geelong Advertiser, the Gold Coast Bulletin, the Herald Sun, The Courier Mail, The Daily Telegraph and The Mercury, headed “Canada school shooter a transgender dropout”.

- Advertisement -

The Press Council found that the article had placed too much emphasis on the offenders status as a person who is transgender, breaching Principle 3 of the Guidelines which relates to fairness and balance, and Principle 6 which calls for publications to avoid causing or contributing materially to substantial offence, distress or prejudice.

The article reported on a mass shooting in Canada saying that “Police have revealed 18-year-old transgender former student Jesse Van Rootselaar murdered their mother and stepbrother before going on a killing spree at a Canadian high school.”

The article reported that Royal Canadian Mounted Police Deputy commissioner Dwyane McDonald had “confirmed during a press conference that Van Rootselaar was born a male and had transitioned six years ago to female.” The article went on to report that “police had visited the shooter’s home on multiple occasions over the last several years due to concerns over Van Rootselaar’s mental health.”

The complaint expressed concern that the prominent and repeated references to Van Rootselaar’s transgender status could lead some readers to conclude that this characteristic was either a cause of, or a significant factor in the reported shootings, and could contribute to substantial prejudice against transgender people.

In response, the publications said they had a responsibility to clearly communicate the facts, including the shooter’s transgender status, which they considered relevant to explaining the use of pronouns. The publications noted that no motive for the shootings had been established and that police had previously attended the shooter’s home due to mental health concerns. They added that the shooter’s transition during childhood and possible isolation in a small community may provide insight into their mental health issues.

The Council noted that the article reported that the police commissioner had said Van Rootselaar was born male and had transitioned to female. However, the article did not report that Van Rootselaar’s transgender status was a cause of, or contributing factor in, the shootings.

The Council stressed that they have repeatedly stated that publications should exercise great care not to place unwarranted emphasis on characteristics of individuals such as race, ethnicity, religion, nationality, country of origin, gender, sexual orientation, marital status, disability, illness or age.

In the absence of a clear link between the shootings and Van Rootselaar’s transgender status, the Council considered that the prominent and repeated references to that characteristic, including in the headline, were not relevant to the substance of the article and were unfair. Accordingly, the Council found that the publications failed to take reasonable steps to ensure that factual material was presented with reasonable fairness and balance, in breach of General Principle 3.

The Council said they recognised that reporting on a mass shooting and on information released by police concerning the alleged perpetrator are matters of legitimate public interest. However, the Council considered that the prominence given to Van Rootselaar’s transgender status could lead some readers to conclude that this characteristic was either a cause of, or a significant factor in, the shootings and could contribute to substantial prejudice against transgender people.

In the absence of a clear link between Van Rootselaar’s transgender status and the shootings, the Council considered that the publications failed to take reasonable steps to avoid contributing materially to substantial prejudice and that there was insufficient public interest justification for the prominent and repeated references. Accordingly, the Council also found a breach of General Principle 6, which call for publications to “avoid causing or contributing materially to substantial offence, distress or prejudice, or a substantial risk to health or safety, unless doing so is sufficiently in the public interest”.

The publications were required to publish the council’s findings on their websites.

See the full adjudication.

Latest

We shouldn’t allow others to set limits on what we can achieve

OPINION Rodney Croome AM is a long-time LGBTIQ+ rights advocate...

Camp classic ‘Can’t Stop the Music’ screens for PRIDEFEST

A PRIDEFEST screening of Can't Stop the Music celebrates the Village People's legacy, queer liberation history and enduring camp appeal.

Queensland police release new photo of Simon Thuijs as search reaches seventh day

Police have released a new image of missing Perth LGBTQIA+ sports leader Simon Thuijs as search efforts continue.

Former Howard government minister Dr Sharman Stone dies aged 75

Former federal minister Sharman Stone has died aged 75, remembered for both her political career and support for transgender women.

Newsletter

Don't miss

We shouldn’t allow others to set limits on what we can achieve

OPINION Rodney Croome AM is a long-time LGBTIQ+ rights advocate...

Camp classic ‘Can’t Stop the Music’ screens for PRIDEFEST

A PRIDEFEST screening of Can't Stop the Music celebrates the Village People's legacy, queer liberation history and enduring camp appeal.

Queensland police release new photo of Simon Thuijs as search reaches seventh day

Police have released a new image of missing Perth LGBTQIA+ sports leader Simon Thuijs as search efforts continue.

Former Howard government minister Dr Sharman Stone dies aged 75

Former federal minister Sharman Stone has died aged 75, remembered for both her political career and support for transgender women.

Crown of the Court is heating up!

Fashion challenges and a lip sync battle saw five performers battle it out to stay in the running for Crown of the Court.

We shouldn’t allow others to set limits on what we can achieve

OPINION Rodney Croome AM is a long-time LGBTIQ+ rights advocate and national spokesperson for Just.Equal What do we deserve and how do we achieve it? That’s the...

Camp classic ‘Can’t Stop the Music’ screens for PRIDEFEST

A PRIDEFEST screening of Can't Stop the Music celebrates the Village People's legacy, queer liberation history and enduring camp appeal.

Queensland police release new photo of Simon Thuijs as search reaches seventh day

Police have released a new image of missing Perth LGBTQIA+ sports leader Simon Thuijs as search efforts continue.