Premium Content:

We shouldn’t allow others to set limits on what we can achieve

Rodney Croome AM is a long-time LGBTIQ+ rights advocate and national spokesperson for Just.Equal


What do we deserve and how do we achieve it?

- Advertisement -

That’s the primary question every LGBTIQA+ advocate has to ask as they embark down the road to reform. 

Let’s take Western Australia’s move to expand LGBTIQA+ discrimination and vilification protections, and the imminent federal government apology to LGBTIQA+ veterans, as they both raise the question.

I agree completely with Misty Farquhar that the WA protections are a valuable step forward for WA’s LGBTIQA+ community which we should all celebrate.

I’d go further and say they matter beyond WA because they increase pressure on the federal government to remove anti-LGBTIQA+ exemptions in national law, and on recalcitrant states like NSW to remove theirs.

But I find it hard to accept Misty’s reasons why more hasn’t been achieved. 

Rodney Croome

Misty claims federal law limits what states can do regarding discrimination.

That’s the argument made by the Catholic Church in Tasmania and Victoria where it is already unlawful for their schools and hospitals to discriminate.

Catholic bodies say state laws are overridden by the national exemptions the Albanese Government promised to remove but then reneged on.

This is not mainstream opinion. I called it out this argument when former WA Attorney General, John Quigley, used it to excuse his lack of action in 2019. It was wrong then and is wrong now.

As far as I know there are no other federal limits on what states can do in this area. 

Misty also says the WA Upper House is a potential obstacle to further reform. 

This strains credibility when the State Labor Government has had the numbers in the Upper House since 2018 and still have a majority when the Greens vote with it, as they will on LGBTIQA+ law reform.

Much more of a worry is that the window for reform in WA may close at the next election if One Nation wins balance-of-power in the Upper House. 

Finally, Misty argues against the possibility of combining reforms to move change faster – let’s say by including a ban on conversion practices and hate crime provisions in the current bill. 

In 2002, the Gallop Labor Government passed an omnibus LGBTIQA+ bill that dealt with age of consent, anti-discrimination, partnership recognition, adoption, and Family Court access.

WA was shot to national LGBTIQA+ leadership.     

If it could be done then, why not now?

As a Tasmanian I also ask, if it can be done here, why not there?

Tasmanians have achieved world-leading reforms regarding LGBTIQA+ discrimination, hate speech, hate crimes, gender recognition and (fingers crossed) banning conversion practices – without the certainty of Upper House support, sometimes without Government support and sometimes in face of trenchant Government opposition.

Each one of those reforms began with the how-do-we-achieve-what-we-need question that started this article, not the question: what are they willing to give us and how do we excuse that?

In the same vein, I also feel we could do better in regard to the proposed national apology to LGBTIQA+ veterans.

It will be given by Deputy Prime Minister and Defence Minister, Richard Marles, next week. 

The equivalent apology in Canada was given by then Prime Minister, Justin Trudeau, and in the UK by its then Prime Minister, Rishi Sunak, who was a Conversative. 

In Australia, Prime Minister Kevin Rudd delivered the Stolen Generation apology and Prime Minister Julia Gillard, the forced adoption apology. 

Our apology should also be lent the gravity and importance of being delivered by the Prime Minister.

Anthony Albanese should deliver it, not his deputy.

Both Canada and the UK also allow mistreated LGBTIQA+ veterans to access financial redress for the injustices they faced, which has barely been discussed in Australia.

If all this seems too far off remember Tasmania has already allowed victims of its former anti-LGBTIQA+ laws to receive financial redress. 

It was also the first state to announce it would offer them an apology from the Premier as the head of government. 

Both of these steps forward happened under Liberal governments.

If we can do that in Tasmania under Liberal governments, why not nationally under Labor? 

The national apology to veterans is an important step forward. I praise the commitment of those who have advocated for it.

But, as with law reform in WA, let’s not accept other people’s limits on what’s possible.

Let’s start with what justice demands and chart a path forward from there.

Latest

Camp classic ‘Can’t Stop the Music’ screens for PRIDEFEST

A PRIDEFEST screening of Can't Stop the Music celebrates the Village People's legacy, queer liberation history and enduring camp appeal.

Queensland police release new photo of Simon Thuijs as search reaches seventh day

Police have released a new image of missing Perth LGBTQIA+ sports leader Simon Thuijs as search efforts continue.

Former Howard government minister Dr Sharman Stone dies aged 75

Former federal minister Sharman Stone has died aged 75, remembered for both her political career and support for transgender women.

Crown of the Court is heating up!

Fashion challenges and a lip sync battle saw five performers battle it out to stay in the running for Crown of the Court.

Newsletter

Don't miss

Camp classic ‘Can’t Stop the Music’ screens for PRIDEFEST

A PRIDEFEST screening of Can't Stop the Music celebrates the Village People's legacy, queer liberation history and enduring camp appeal.

Queensland police release new photo of Simon Thuijs as search reaches seventh day

Police have released a new image of missing Perth LGBTQIA+ sports leader Simon Thuijs as search efforts continue.

Former Howard government minister Dr Sharman Stone dies aged 75

Former federal minister Sharman Stone has died aged 75, remembered for both her political career and support for transgender women.

Crown of the Court is heating up!

Fashion challenges and a lip sync battle saw five performers battle it out to stay in the running for Crown of the Court.

Equal Opportunity Commissioner Dr John Byrne to stand down

Equal Opportunity Commissioner Dr John Byrne will leave his role in December after a decade of leading the WA commission.

Camp classic ‘Can’t Stop the Music’ screens for PRIDEFEST

A PRIDEFEST screening of Can't Stop the Music celebrates the Village People's legacy, queer liberation history and enduring camp appeal.

Queensland police release new photo of Simon Thuijs as search reaches seventh day

Police have released a new image of missing Perth LGBTQIA+ sports leader Simon Thuijs as search efforts continue.

Former Howard government minister Dr Sharman Stone dies aged 75

Former federal minister Sharman Stone has died aged 75, remembered for both her political career and support for transgender women.