Premium Content:

Good Gay, Bad Gay in the Naughties

Going in for a HIV/STI screen should be as normal and as easy as walking into the local deli for a carton of milk.

So, why do so many guys feel that it is more like walking into a sex shop for the first time – filled with anxiety, shame and embarrassment? The answer lay in the myth that ‘good gays’ shouldn’t need a sexual health screen.

- Advertisement -

After a number of online sexual behaviour surveys into gay men’s activities, the Australian Research Centre in Sex, Health and Society social researchers have noted there is an interesting phenomenon arising out of a post-HIV world – the ‘good gay/bad gay’ dichotomy.

A ‘good gay’, apparently, stays at home with his partner (who is also a ‘good gay’), believing neither of them need a sexual health screen because they don’t have sex with other guys, so of course they would never have an STI.

‘Bad gays’, conversely, have loads of sexual partners and go for STI screens- sometimes proudly, and sometimes with a sense of shame. It’s even worse if they have an STI, God forbid!

The social researchers received lots of ‘good gay’ responses to their surveys, but had a hell of a time finding those happy to admit to a robust sex life. This skewed the data and just didn’t gel with the level of STI notifications nationwide. How could so many claim to be ‘good gays’ and yet we have increasing levels of Chlamydia, Gonorrhoea and Syphilis?

One theory is gay men are hesitant to be honest with themselves and their partners about their activities. For fear of being branded a ‘bad gay’, many guys will also resist getting a regular STI screen. When anxious sexual partners ask that irksome question, ‘are you clean?’ they can, in all good conscience and within their knowledge, answer honestly, ‘yes’. But without testing how can they really know?

For many years, gay men have been finger-wagged into submission about promiscuity. Claiming sex as fun and pleasurable, albeit doing it safely, is a difficult renaissance. Increases in HIV/STI notifications shows that at least some of these devoted ‘good gays’ are, on the odd occasion, dabbling in the darker side of things – unprepared, under-resourced and unknowledgeable. Therein lays the danger.

The message is simple, really. A regular STI screen is a socially responsible act. It doesn’t make you a bad gay.

For more information about STI’s, HIV and testing, contact the WA AIDS Council on 9482 0000 or waac@waaids.com

Project X team

***

Latest

We shouldn’t allow others to set limits on what we can achieve

OPINION Rodney Croome AM is a long-time LGBTIQ+ rights advocate...

Camp classic ‘Can’t Stop the Music’ screens for PRIDEFEST

A PRIDEFEST screening of Can't Stop the Music celebrates the Village People's legacy, queer liberation history and enduring camp appeal.

Today is Transgender Day of Remembrance

Transgender Day of Remembrance honours lives lost to anti-trans violence while advocates call for accessible healthcare and stronger support.

Queensland police release new photo of Simon Thuijs as search reaches seventh day

Police have released a new image of missing Perth LGBTQIA+ sports leader Simon Thuijs as search efforts continue.

Newsletter

Don't miss

We shouldn’t allow others to set limits on what we can achieve

OPINION Rodney Croome AM is a long-time LGBTIQ+ rights advocate...

Camp classic ‘Can’t Stop the Music’ screens for PRIDEFEST

A PRIDEFEST screening of Can't Stop the Music celebrates the Village People's legacy, queer liberation history and enduring camp appeal.

Today is Transgender Day of Remembrance

Transgender Day of Remembrance honours lives lost to anti-trans violence while advocates call for accessible healthcare and stronger support.

Queensland police release new photo of Simon Thuijs as search reaches seventh day

Police have released a new image of missing Perth LGBTQIA+ sports leader Simon Thuijs as search efforts continue.

Former Howard government minister Dr Sharman Stone dies aged 75

Former federal minister Sharman Stone has died aged 75, remembered for both her political career and support for transgender women.

We shouldn’t allow others to set limits on what we can achieve

OPINION Rodney Croome AM is a long-time LGBTIQ+ rights advocate and national spokesperson for Just.Equal What do we deserve and how do we achieve it? That’s the...

Camp classic ‘Can’t Stop the Music’ screens for PRIDEFEST

A PRIDEFEST screening of Can't Stop the Music celebrates the Village People's legacy, queer liberation history and enduring camp appeal.

Today is Transgender Day of Remembrance

Transgender Day of Remembrance honours lives lost to anti-trans violence while advocates call for accessible healthcare and stronger support.