Premium Content:

Alex Greenwich faces backlash over call for Fred Nile state funeral

New South Wales independent MP Alex Greenwich is facing criticism for his call for former Christian Democratic Party leader Reverend Fred Nile to be granted a state funeral.

Nile, the longest-serving politician in the history of the New South Wales Parliament, spent decades campaigning against LGBTIQA+ rights, including calling for the Sydney Gay and Lesbian Mardi Gras to be closed down and opposing same-sex parenting and marriage equality. He died yesterday at the age of 92.

- Advertisement -

Greenwich, a prominent advocate for marriage equality who campaigned on the YES side of the 2017 postal survey, was among the first public figures to pay tribute to Nile following his death. He revealed on social media that he had written to Premier Chris Minns requesting a state funeral in recognition of Nile’s lengthy parliamentary service.

Alex Greenwich.

Greenwich noted that he worked closely with Nile during his final years in Parliament and said they had collaborated on several pieces of legislation.

“Towards the end of his time in NSW Parliament, I formed a good working relationship with Fred to progress the protection of First Nations cultural sites. Rev. Nile also played a key role in passing legislation for the expungement of prior homosexual convictions, landmark laws that cleared the names of hundreds of gay men,” Greenwich said.

“It goes without saying that we disagreed a lot, however we did so in an adult way. Fred would remark to me how unfair he thought people like Mark Latham and Lyle Shelton were.

“This morning I sent the Premier a message requesting a state service to honour Rev. Nile’s service to NSW.”

When followers expressed dismay at the proposal given Nile’s long history of opposition to LGBTIQA+ rights, Greenwich said he understood that not everyone would agree with his position and highlighted what he described as a change in Nile’s views in his final years.

“In 2022, Rev. Nile apologised for the harm caused to our community and voted for a number of reforms to protect us in his final term. When someone acknowledges wrongdoing and then takes steps to make good, I will always choose forgiveness. I respect that people have different views,” Greenwich said.

Writer Peter FitzSimons also reflected on an interview he conducted with Nile in which the former politician acknowledged that some of his remarks about LGBTIQA+ people and Mardi Gras had been hurtful.

As FitzSimons recounted, Nile described some of his comments as “probably” having been “a little bit on the mean side of things”.

“Yes, probably was, and upsetting their lives,” Nile said. Pushed by Fitzsimons he added “I’m sorry”.

Nile also reportedly described some of his comments about Muslims as “a bit extreme” and apologised to his “Muslim brothers and sisters”.

Former New South Wales premier Bob Carr paid tribute to Nile, describing him as “an honourable man” who always honoured political agreements.

Carr also suggested that some of Nile’s public condemnations of Mardi Gras may have been aimed at appealing to his supporter base.

“I think a lot of these colourful, apocalyptic condemnations of the Mardi Gras were about that,” Carr said.

“I’m not sure, especially in years past, how much he actually believed it.”

The Reverend Fred Nile.

Long History of Opposition to LGBTIQA+ Rights

Nile was first elected to the New South Wales Parliament in 1981. Aside from a brief period in 2004 when he resigned to contest a federal Senate seat, he served in the Legislative Council for more than 40 years before retiring in 2023.

Throughout much of his political career, Nile described homosexuality as a “mental disorder” and as “immoral, unnatural and abnormal”.

He was a longstanding opponent of the Sydney Gay and Lesbian Mardi Gras and held annual prayer gatherings in opposition to the event. He once described Mardi Gras as “a public parade of immorality and blasphemy”.

While Nile said he opposed violence against gay and lesbian people and condemned physical attacks on them, he also argued that New South Wales’ vilification protections covering LGBTIQA+ people should be removed, claiming they restricted public debate.

Nile campaigned against marriage equality and criticised same-sex couples who chose to start families, including Senator Penny Wong and her now-wife Sophie Allouache.

In 2011, Nile said: “I’m totally against a baby being brought up by two mothers.”

“She needn’t have made it public. It just promotes their lesbian lifestyle and tries to make it natural when it’s unnatural.”

Although Nile made no reference to LGBTIQA+ issues in his valedictory speech to Parliament in November 2022, he later participated in a protest calling for The Project to be taken off air following comments made by queer comedian Reuben Kaye.

Community Figures Question Praise for Nile

Former Australian Democrats senator Brian Greig was among those who criticised Greenwich’s tribute.

“Words fail me,” Greig wrote.

Greig recalled introducing legislation that would have made genocide a criminal offence and said Nile appeared before parliamentary hearings to oppose the bill because it included protections for LGBTIQA+ people.

“Fred attended one such hearing to oppose the bill. Why? Because the bill covered LGBTI people within the definition of those subject to genocide,” Greig said.

Greig further alleged that Nile dismissed evidence relating to the persecution of gay people during the Holocaust.

“The notion that Fred was old-fashioned or benign beggars belief. He denied the evidence of the Holocaust, ignored the existence of museums such as Mauthausen, and claimed to be ignorant of the origin of the pink triangle. Words fail me,” Greig said.

Greens MP Cate Faehrmann also questioned the call for a state funeral.

“A state funeral should be reserved to honour people whose life’s work is of extreme significance and value to the state and its people,” Faehrmann said.

“They should not be held for those who spent most of their lives preaching hate towards some, regardless of any ‘redemption’ in their final years of life.”

Greenwich’s social media accounts were also flooded with responses from community members who shared experiences of homophobia and transphobia throughout the 1980s and 1990s, with many arguing that Nile’s activism contributed to those experiences and broader social stigma.

Greenwich Apologises for Causing Hurt

Later in the day, Greenwich issued a further statement apologising for the distress caused by his initial comments, although he did not withdraw his request for a state funeral.

“I want to acknowledge that my previous post about the passing of Rev. Nile triggered and upset a lot of people, and I am sorry.

“I’m grateful for those who spoke with me today about their experience of the impact Fred Nile’s words and actions had in the 1980s and 1990s.

“I always try and work with people across the political spectrum on outcomes for our community. I took that approach with Rev. Nile and, at the end, he opened his heart and mind, apologised for the harm he caused and supported a number of LGBTQIA+ reforms.

“Fred’s change of heart late in life didn’t erase the hurt, pain and discrimination that came from his earlier campaigns, and I’m sorry for the upset I have caused.”

Latest

Anti-LGBTIQA+ campaigner Fred Nile dies aged 92

Former NSW politician Fred Nile has died aged 92. Alex Greenwich has called for a state funeral.

On This Gay Day | Benjamin Britten was born in 1913

A central figure in music in the 20th century Britten composed well known operas, orchestral and vocal music.

Victorian Labor promises $7.2 million for Pride Street Party if re-elected

Victoria Labor has pledged $7.2 million for Melbourne's Pride Street Party and proposed a possible move to Saturdays from 2028.

Head to the Swan Pride Festival for a multi-cultural celebration

The Pride Swan Festival is a free, family-friendly and inclusive community celebration recognising the diversity, resilience and contributions of LGBTQIA+ communities across Western Australia.

Newsletter

Don't miss

Anti-LGBTIQA+ campaigner Fred Nile dies aged 92

Former NSW politician Fred Nile has died aged 92. Alex Greenwich has called for a state funeral.

On This Gay Day | Benjamin Britten was born in 1913

A central figure in music in the 20th century Britten composed well known operas, orchestral and vocal music.

Victorian Labor promises $7.2 million for Pride Street Party if re-elected

Victoria Labor has pledged $7.2 million for Melbourne's Pride Street Party and proposed a possible move to Saturdays from 2028.

Head to the Swan Pride Festival for a multi-cultural celebration

The Pride Swan Festival is a free, family-friendly and inclusive community celebration recognising the diversity, resilience and contributions of LGBTQIA+ communities across Western Australia.

Channeling Run DMC, Road Safety Minister Jessica Stojkovski wants people to “walk this way”

A new $1 million partnership will guide FRINGE WORLD audiences safely through Northbridge with signage, activations and amenities.

Anti-LGBTIQA+ campaigner Fred Nile dies aged 92

Former NSW politician Fred Nile has died aged 92. Alex Greenwich has called for a state funeral.

On This Gay Day | Benjamin Britten was born in 1913

A central figure in music in the 20th century Britten composed well known operas, orchestral and vocal music.

Victorian Labor promises $7.2 million for Pride Street Party if re-elected

Victoria Labor has pledged $7.2 million for Melbourne's Pride Street Party and proposed a possible move to Saturdays from 2028.