Premium Content:

OPINION | The law reform bill is good – but can be much better

Brian Greig is a spokesperson for rights group Just.Equal. In 1995 he was the first gay person, who had publicly shared their sexuality, to be elected to public office in Western Australia when he served on the City of Vincent Council. He represented Western Australia in the Australian Senate from 1999 until 2005 as a member of the Australian Democrats.


The Cook Government’s Equal Opportunity Bill is a major step forward — but some loopholes risk leaving our community behind.

- Advertisement -

The Western Australian Government finally tabled its long-awaited, 173-page Equal Opportunity Bill 2026 on 21 October.

For the LGBTIQA+ community, this is the moment for which we’ve been waiting. It promises to drag WA’s outdated anti-discrimination laws into the modern era by tackling religious exemptions, anti-vilification, and trans protections.

But while the headlines look great, some of the fine print tells a different story. If we look past the media releases, we find some unpleasant loopholes, worryingly high legal bars, and baffling omissions.

It is a massive step forward to be sure, but if we don’t fix it now it risks leaving our community exposed.

The Good: Ending the “sack and expel” era

Let’s start with the clear wins. For years, publicly funded religious schools and faith-based services have held a legal license to discriminate. They could fire a teacher, expel a student, or deny employment to an aged care worker simply for being LGBTIQA+.

This bill finally ends that. Faith-based hospitals, aged care facilities, housing charities, disability support, and schools will no longer be allowed to discriminate in hiring, firing, or service delivery.

It brings WA into line with most of the country. This is a monumental victory for advocates who have fought for decades to close these special religious exemptions. (Shout out to Craig Campbell).

The Bad: Adoption and rainbow families

Unfortunately, the celebrations falter when you hit section 59. In a cruel twist, the bill carves out an exception for child adoption, effectively legalising discrimination against rainbow families.

This is bizarre, given that same-sex couples have been able to legally adopt in WA since 2002, and to foster children long before that.

What makes this worse is that it is more regressive than New South Wales, which at least limits adoption discrimination to faith-based agencies only. The WA bill excludes all adoption decisions from standard discrimination rules.

Adoption services have traditionally sat outside the Equal Opportunity Act because providers must evaluate an applicant’s capacity to provide a suitable home.

This means considering a range of factors like age, health, cultural background, and race (eg: indigenous children) which require specific legal frameworks so providers aren’t accused of discrimination during standard assessments.

However, adoption services shouldn’t be allowed to lock out LGBTIQA+ people either. At the very least, this exception must be narrowed to prohibit discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation, gender identity, and sex characteristics.

The Ugly: Anti-vilification rules almost impossible to use

The bill introduces much-anticipated anti-vilification protections to shield us from public hate speech. However, the government has set the legal bar so high to progress a complaint that it may be almost impossible for victims to win.

Under the proposed law, vilifying a person or group means:

(a) expressing and inciting hatred, serious contempt, or severe ridicule; or

(b) threatening, seriously abusing, and inciting threats or serious abuse.

The trap here is the word inciting. The victim must prove that the speech or text actually stirred up hatred or threats in others. Most other states only require you to prove that the vilification was likely to cause that reaction.

Proving actual incitement in a courtroom is a huge hurdle. The Law Reform Commission of WA (LRCWA) recommended focusing on the “likely” impact, but the government ignored this.

Furthermore, the bill splits hate speech into two categories, making one of them practically useless:

  • Category A (The realistic path): Covers speech that stirs up hatred, contempt, or ridicule. You only have to prove one of these things happened. This is a fair standard.
  • Category B (The impossible path): Covers threats and serious abuse. Because of how the law is worded, a victim must prove the abuser did three things at once: threatened, seriously abused, and incited threats or abuse. If just one element is missing, the case fails. In Victoria, NSW, and Tasmania, proving any one of these elements is enough.

To top it off, while the bill expands protections against sexual and racial harassment, it fails to add specific protections for harassment based on sexuality, gender identity, or sex characteristics.

There is no logical reason our community shouldn’t be protected from everyday harassment to the same degree as others.

Currently, the Equal Opportunity Act bans discrimination in the workplace. Employers cannot use outdated workplace instruments to justify treating staff unfairly.

However, a significant drafting error in the bill states that any discriminatory actions authorised by a state award or agreement will no longer be considered “unlawful conduct”.

Many state awards are decades old and contain outdated, discriminatory clauses that are currently unenforceable because of our existing anti-discrimination laws. If this bill passes as written, employers could legally enforce ancient rules that:

  • Exclude LGBTIQA+ couples or de facto partners from workplace benefits by only recognising opposite-sex partners or married couples.
  • Restrict female workers from certain tasks, like operating heavy machinery or climbing ladders.
  • Discriminate on the grounds of sex, such as only allowing female workers to work part-time or take paid breaks. 

This error accidentally revives discriminatory rules from a bygone era and protects them under the law for the first time in decades.

What the bill misses entirely

Most disappointing is what didn’t make the cut. In recent months, the government has expressed genuine concern over targeted hate crimes, such as the violent entrapment attacks and the general rising tide of menace against LGBTIQA+ people.  

Yet hate crimes are not addressed in this tranche of reforms.

Similarly, a ban on harmful LGBTIQA+ conversion and suppression practices remains untouched. With Tasmania moving to ban this currently, WA is left as the last remaining state that has not tackled the issue.

It is deeply frustrating that despite a decade in government, Labor has not delivered legislation on these matters.

The verdict: Time to amend

The intent behind the Equal Opportunity Bill 2026 is very good, but parliament must fix the fine print.

Attorney General Tony Buti and our allies in the Legislative Council have the power to repair this before it passes into law. We need five commitments:

  1. Narrow adoption exemptions: Stop discrimination against rainbow families.
  2. Lower the vilification bar: Change the wording so victims need only prove hate speech was likely to cause harm, bringing WA in line with other states and the LRCWA recommendation.
  3. Expand harassment protections: Explicitly protect our community from targeted harassment based on sexuality, gender identity and sex characteristics.
  4. Fix the workplace loophole: Ensure outdated, discriminatory award terms cannot be enforced.
  5. Deliver on hate crimes and conversion practices: The government must pledge to introduce bills to ban conversion practices and tackle hate crimes before the next election.

The Cook Government has given us the legislative bones of a fairer Western Australia. Now, it’s up to our community and parliamentary allies to give it the teeth it needs to truly protect us.

Latest

We shouldn’t allow others to set limits on what we can achieve

OPINION Rodney Croome AM is a long-time LGBTIQ+ rights advocate...

Camp classic ‘Can’t Stop the Music’ screens for PRIDEFEST

A PRIDEFEST screening of Can't Stop the Music celebrates the Village People's legacy, queer liberation history and enduring camp appeal.

Today is Transgender Day of Remembrance

Transgender Day of Remembrance honours lives lost to anti-trans violence while advocates call for accessible healthcare and stronger support.

Queensland police release new photo of Simon Thuijs as search reaches seventh day

Police have released a new image of missing Perth LGBTQIA+ sports leader Simon Thuijs as search efforts continue.

Newsletter

Don't miss

We shouldn’t allow others to set limits on what we can achieve

OPINION Rodney Croome AM is a long-time LGBTIQ+ rights advocate...

Camp classic ‘Can’t Stop the Music’ screens for PRIDEFEST

A PRIDEFEST screening of Can't Stop the Music celebrates the Village People's legacy, queer liberation history and enduring camp appeal.

Today is Transgender Day of Remembrance

Transgender Day of Remembrance honours lives lost to anti-trans violence while advocates call for accessible healthcare and stronger support.

Queensland police release new photo of Simon Thuijs as search reaches seventh day

Police have released a new image of missing Perth LGBTQIA+ sports leader Simon Thuijs as search efforts continue.

Former Howard government minister Dr Sharman Stone dies aged 75

Former federal minister Sharman Stone has died aged 75, remembered for both her political career and support for transgender women.

We shouldn’t allow others to set limits on what we can achieve

OPINION Rodney Croome AM is a long-time LGBTIQ+ rights advocate and national spokesperson for Just.Equal What do we deserve and how do we achieve it? That’s the...

Camp classic ‘Can’t Stop the Music’ screens for PRIDEFEST

A PRIDEFEST screening of Can't Stop the Music celebrates the Village People's legacy, queer liberation history and enduring camp appeal.

Today is Transgender Day of Remembrance

Transgender Day of Remembrance honours lives lost to anti-trans violence while advocates call for accessible healthcare and stronger support.