Premium Content:

Federal US court rules against trans discrimination in landmark case

The US Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit has ruled in favour of a young transgender student’s right to use the bathroom that aligns with their gender in a high-profile case.

- Advertisement -

The court, which presides over the states of Illinois, Wisconsin and Indiana, found that the Kenosha Unified School District could not prevent trans student Ash Whitaker from using the bathroom of their choosing.

“The School District has not demonstrated that it will suffer any harm from having to comply with the district court’s preliminary injunction order,” the three judge panel unanimously ruled.

The judges found that Whitaker should be protected by sex discrimination protections under Title IX of the US’ Education Amendments of 1972, and that the district’s anti-trans bathroom policy conflicted with the constitution’s Fourteenth Amendment Equal Protection Clause.

“A policy that requires an individual to use a bathroom that does not conform with his or her gender identity punishes that individual for his or her gender non‐conformance, which in turn violates Title IX,” Judge Ann Claire Williams wrote.

“The School District argues that since it treats all boys and girls the same, it does not violate the Equal Protection Clause. This is untrue, rather, the School District treats transgender students like Ash, who fail to conform to the sex‐based stereotypes associated with their assigned sex at birth, differently.”

Judge Williams said the school district failed to convince the courts with evidence that violation of their anti-trans bathroom policy would harm students or parents.

“The harms identified by the School District are all speculative and based upon conjecture, whereas the harms to Ash are well‐documented and supported by the record.”

OIP Staff

Latest

City of Subiaco to help local creatives build their careers

Elise Wilson and Sophie Minissale will be sponsored to attend the BANDWIDTH Amplify program.

WA government says its still progressing plan to address conversion therapy

Roger Cook first began tackling the issue as Health Minister in 2017.

Thorne Harbour Health CEO Simon Ruth to step down

Ruth has lead the Victorian based organisation for 12 years.

Walkern Wirin: Boorloo Blak Pride will be part of PrideFEST 2025

An event to honour all LGBTIQA+ First Nations people, alongside their supportive friends and family.

Newsletter

Don't miss

City of Subiaco to help local creatives build their careers

Elise Wilson and Sophie Minissale will be sponsored to attend the BANDWIDTH Amplify program.

WA government says its still progressing plan to address conversion therapy

Roger Cook first began tackling the issue as Health Minister in 2017.

Thorne Harbour Health CEO Simon Ruth to step down

Ruth has lead the Victorian based organisation for 12 years.

Walkern Wirin: Boorloo Blak Pride will be part of PrideFEST 2025

An event to honour all LGBTIQA+ First Nations people, alongside their supportive friends and family.

Associate Professor Michelle Telfer nominated for Human Rights Award

See all the nominees for the 2025 Human Rights Awards.

City of Subiaco to help local creatives build their careers

Elise Wilson and Sophie Minissale will be sponsored to attend the BANDWIDTH Amplify program.

WA government says its still progressing plan to address conversion therapy

Roger Cook first began tackling the issue as Health Minister in 2017.

Thorne Harbour Health CEO Simon Ruth to step down

Ruth has lead the Victorian based organisation for 12 years.