The Marriage Alliance, one of Australia’s leading lobby groups against marriage equality, has posted a bizarre claim to their social media channel alleging that a Norwegian child protection case is a consequence of allowing same sex marriages.
On their Twitter channel the Marriage Alliance posted an image of a story in the conservative newspaper the Washington Times.
The story, which has appeared in many religious based publications, claims that the children of a Norwegian-Romanian family were removed from their parents care because of the parent’s Christian beliefs.
Alongside the image of the story the Marriage Alliance posted the message, “Norway passed marriage equality in 2009, and here are the consequences.” The group then asked, “Is this the Australia we want to become?”.
The story in The Washington Times, a conservative newspaper founded by religious groups, claims that the Norwegian department of child services, known as Barnevernet, removed five children from the care of their parents Marius and Ruth Bodnariu.
The Washington Times article claims that the children were removed because of their parent’s Christian beliefs. There has also been some suggestion that the children were removed because of physical abuse as the parents believed in corporal punishment.
In an interview with the BBC, Ruth Bodnariu admitted that the parents did spank their children, something which is illegal under Norwegian law.
The Washington Times story linked to a video from the Home School Legal Defense Association, a Christian association that describes itself as a voice to defend parental rights. The group is opposed to marriage equality as they believe it violates parents rights.
As Norwegian law requires the government to respect the privacy of both the parents and the children, no official comment has ever been made by Barnevernet.
Religious groups have protested the move claiming that the Marius and Ruth Bodnariu were being persecuted for their Pentecostal faith. However the Leader Council of the Pentecostal Movement in Norway released a statement earlier this year stating that they did not believe Norwegians were being discriminated or persecuted.
The Marriage Alliance has not elaborated on how the Scandinavian countries passing of marriage equality seven years ago has lead to the removal of the families children, or how allowing marriage equality in Australia would trigger a change in how we allow parents to discipline their children.
Recently the group highlighted that they were a secular organisation and were not a religious lobby group.
The Marriage Alliance was nominated for a GLORIA award for making offensive and ridiculous statements about LGBTI people, but was nominated in the Religious category. The group argued that this was inappropriate as they are not a religious group.
The Marriage Alliance was contacted for comment.
Tags: Barnevernet, Bodnariu, corporal punishment, gay, Lesbian, Marriage, Marriage Alliance, Norway, transgender, TwitterOUTinPerth is news website focusing on diversity in sexuality and gender. Established in 2002, OUTinPerth was a print magazine until 2019 when it became a fully digital publication.
OUTinPerth is created on the land of the Whadjuk people of the Noongar nation. We acknowledge Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people as the Traditional Custodians of this country and its waters, and pay our respect to Elders past and present.
OUTinPerth is owned by Speirins Media Pty Ltd. P.O. Box 69, Gosnells, 6990.
Help create OUTinPerth. We're always looking for writers, researchers and creative people. Find out more here.
The publication of the name, photograph or likeness of any person within this this site in no way implies anything about their sexuality or gender identity.
Copyright on contributions to and ads published in OUTinPerth is retained by the author/advertiser respectively. Permission to reprint should be sought via the Editor.
The views of this publication are contained in editorials. Opinions expressed in columns or articles are those of the author/s and do not necessarily reflect those of the publisher.
Advertisers are advised that all advertising copy is their responsibility under the Trade Practices Act. The appearance of any advert/advertorial herein does not imply endorsement by OUTinPerth.